State if the following statement is true or false. Give reasons for your answers in the form of a short proof or a counterexample.
(√2, 1, ½) E Q X Z X R.
The statement is false because .
Proof that :
Suppose is rational. That mean it can be writen as the ratio of two inegers and
(1)
where we may assume that and have no common factors. (If there are any common factors we cancel tham in the numerator and denominator.) Squaring in (1) on both sides gives
(2)
which impiels
(3)
Thus is even. The only way this can be true is that itself is even. But then is actually divisible by . Hence and therefore must me even. So and are both even which is a contradiction to our assumption that they have no common factor. The square root of 2 cannot be rational.
Comments