Question #216787

Let Y be a subspace of a metric space (X, d). Then show that ๐นโІ๐‘Œ is closed in Y if and only if

๐น=๐‘Œโˆฉ๐ป for some closed subset H of X.


1
Expert's answer
2021-07-15T08:24:49-0400
  • Let us suppose that FโІYF\subseteq Y is such that there exists a closed set HโІXH\subseteq X such that F=HโˆฉYF=H\cap Y. Suppose that (xn)nโˆˆN(x_n)_{n\in \mathbb{N}} is a sequence of elements of FF that admits a limit xx in YY (i.e. xnโ†’xx_n\to x and xโˆˆYx\in Y). As FโІHF\subseteq H and HH is closed, we have xโˆˆHx\in H (as we can view the sequence xnx_n as a sequence in XX). As xโˆˆH,xโˆˆYx\in H, x\in Y, we have xโˆˆHโˆฉY=Fx\in H\cap Y = F. Therefore, FF is closed in YY.
  • Now let us suppose that FโІYF\subseteq Y is closed in YY. We take H:=Fห‰H:= \bar{F} and we will prove that indeed F=YโˆฉHF=Y\cap H. As FโІYF\subseteq Y and FโІFห‰F\subseteq \bar{F} we have FโІYโˆฉHF\subseteq Y\cap H. Now let xโˆˆYโˆฉHx\in Y\cap H. As xโˆˆFห‰x\in \bar{F}, there exists a sequence (xn)nโˆˆN(x_n)_{n\in \mathbb{N}} of elements of FF such that xnโ†’xx_n\to x in XX . As xโˆˆYx\in Y, we also have that xnโ†’xx_n\to x in YY. Finally, as FF is closed in YY, we have xโˆˆFx\in F (as it is a limit in YY of elements of FF). Therefore, YโˆฉHโІFY\cap H \subseteq F and by the double inclusion we conclude that F=YโˆฉHF=Y\cap H for a closed subset HH of XX.

Need a fast expert's response?

Submit order

and get a quick answer at the best price

for any assignment or question with DETAILED EXPLANATIONS!

Comments

No comments. Be the first!
LATEST TUTORIALS
APPROVED BY CLIENTS