Let Y be a subspace of a metric space (X, d). Then show that ๐นโ๐ is closed in Y if and only if
๐น=๐โฉ๐ป for some closed subset H of X.
1
Expert's answer
2021-07-15T08:24:49-0400
Let us suppose that FโY is such that there exists a closed set HโX such that F=HโฉY. Suppose that (xnโ)nโNโ is a sequence of elements of F that admits a limit x in Y (i.e. xnโโx and xโY). As FโH and H is closed, we have xโH (as we can view the sequence xnโ as a sequence in X). As xโH,xโY, we have xโHโฉY=F. Therefore, F is closed in Y.
Now let us suppose that FโY is closed in Y. We take H:=Fห and we will prove that indeed F=YโฉH. As FโY and FโFห we have FโYโฉH. Now let xโYโฉH. As xโFห, there exists a sequence (xnโ)nโNโ of elements of F such that xnโโx in X . As xโY, we also have that xnโโx in Y. Finally, as F is closed in Y, we have xโF (as it is a limit in Y of elements of F). Therefore, YโฉHโF and by the double inclusion we conclude that F=YโฉH for a closed subset H of X.
Comments