Answer to Question #309219 in Law for Rethabile

Question

(i) X1 is charged with the murder of A. Briefly state which ground of justification X1 can rely on and give reasons for your answer. (Do not give the definition of the defence and do not discuss all the requirements of it. Confine your answer to the relevant requirement/s of the defence.) (3) (ii) B is charged with the murder of X3. Briefly state, in one sentence, whether B may raise the same defence as X1 and give a reason for your answer. (3) (iii) State which ground of justification B may rely on and briefly consider whether he can succeed. (Do not give the definition of the defence and do not discuss all the requirements of it. Confine your answer to discussing the relevant requirement of the defence.)