1. Consider the following model of a hypothetical market for MSW management services:
MPB = 18.35 − 2Q
MPC = 2 + Q
MEC = 0.25Q,
where Q is the number of trash containers per household per month.
A. Quantitatively determine the effect of the resource misallocation due to:
i. the presence of the negative externality, and
ii. the use of a flat fee pricing system in the presence of a negative externality.
B. Determine the dollar value of a waste-end charge that would restore efficiency to this market. Explain your answer intuitively.
Hypothetical market for MSW management service:
Demand (D) : MPB = 18.35 – 2Q
Supply ( S ) : MPC = 2 + Q
DEMAND = SUPPLY for equilibrium
18.35 – 2 Q = 2 + Q
16.35 = 3 Q
3 Q = 16.35
Q = 5.45
Equilibrium quantity is Q = 5.45 at price
P = 18.35 – 2 Q = 18.35 – 2 (5.45)
P = 18.35 – 10.9 = 7.45
P = 7.45
The above equilibrium is when externality is not incorporated in supply function.When we consider the cost of externality supply function is S| = MPC + MEC
2 + Q + 0.25 Q
Demand = S|
18.35 – 2Q = 2 + 1.25 Q
16.35 = 3.25 Q
3.25 Q = 16.35
Q = 16.35/3.25
Q1 = 5.03
When cost of externality is considered, output reduced to Q1= 5.03
Resource mis allocation or 1 unit extra will be provided in the market if negative externality is not considered.
ii) Flat fee pricing system is when a flat fee is charged for waste generated irrespective of quantity Therefore marginal private cost of additional waste management service is zero.
MPC = 0
Equilibrium is where MPB = MPC
18.35 – 2 Q = 0
2Q = 18.35
Q2 = 9.175
Resource mis allocation is 9.175 – 5.45 = 3.725.units extra service demanded and supplies in case of flat fee pricing system.
B. Waste and charge is a free charged at the time of disposal of waste.It is used based on the quantity of waste generated.To restore efficiency,dollar value waste – end charge should be equal to MPC + MEC at the socially optimum level of output so it comes both private cost of waste + cost of externality. Socially optimum level of output is Q1= 5.03 marginal social cost at this output is PE = 8.2875 . Therefore fee of $ 8.28/unit .
Comments
Leave a comment