Answer to Question #302208 in Thermal Power Engineering for Shanha

Question

An inventor claims to have developed a heat engine that receives 700 kJ of heat from a source at 500 K and produces 300 I of net work. while rejecting the waste heat to a sink at 290 K. Is this reasonable claim?

Answer 1

The maximum heat efficiency of the engine is the Carnot efficiency;

$\eta_{Carnot}=1-\frac{T_2}{T_1}=1-\frac{290}{500}=0.42$

Since efficiency is defined as;

$\eta=\frac{work}{Heat}$

$0.42=\frac{W}{700}$

$W=294kJ$

Therefore it is impossible to have a work output greater than 294kJ and therefore the inventors claim is not reasonable.