Farmer Jones and Farmer Smith graze their cattle in the same field. If there are 50 cows grazing in the field, each cow produces $50,000 of milk over its lifetime. If there are more cows in the field, then each cow can eat less grass and its milk production falls. With 70 cows in the field, each produces $85000 of milk; with 100 cows, each produces $1,10,000 of milk. Cows cost $1500 each.
a). Assume that Farmer Jones and Farmer Smith can each purchase either 25 or 50 cows, but that neither knows how many the other is buying when she makes her purchase. Calculate the pay-offs of each outcome.
b). Fill in the pay-offs in a 2 × 2 decision box.
c). What is the likely outcome of this game? What would be the best outcome? Explain.
d). There used to be more common grazing land than there is today. Why?
Answer:
a.
Case 1:-
Farmer Jones buys 25 cows
Farmer Smith buys 25 cows.
Total cows are 25+25= 50
Therefore, Farmer Jones generated revenue = $50,000x25 = $1,250,000
And, Farmer Smith generated revenue of $50,000x25= $1,250,000
When the price of cows is substracted we get,
Farmer Jones profit = $1,250,000 - (1500x25) = $1,212,500
Farmer Smith = $1,250,000 - (1500x25) = $1,212,500
Case 2:-
Farmer Smith buys 25 cows and Farmer Jones buys 50 cows.
The total number of cows will be 25+50= 75
Therefore, Farmer Jones generated revenue of $85,000x50 = $4,250,000
And, Farmer Smith generated revenue = $85000x25 = $2,125,000
When you substract the price of the cows, we get,
Farmer Jones profit is $4,250,000 - $1500x50 = $4,175,000
Farmer Smith profit is $2,125,000 - $1500x25 = $2,087,500
Case 3:-
Farmer Smith buys 50 cows and farmer Jones purchases 25 cows
The total number of cows will be 50+25 = 75
Therefore, Farmer Jones generated revenue of $85,000x25 = $2,125,000
And, Farmer Smith generated revenue = $85000x50 = $4,250,000
When you substract the price of the cows, we get,
Farmer Jones profit is $2,125,000 - $1500x25 = $2,087,500
Farmer Smith profit is $4,250,000 - $1500x50 = $4,175,000
Case 4:-
Farmer Jones buys 50 cows
Farmer Smith buys 50 cows.
The total number of cows on field will be 50+50= 100
Therefore, farmer Jones generated revenue of $110,000x50
And, farmer Smith generated revenue of= $110,000x50
When you substract the price of the cows, we get,
Farmer Jones profit = $5,500,000 - 150050 = $5,425,000
Farmer Smith profit = $5,500,000 - 150050 = $5,425,000
b.
c. From the calculations done in question (a), the highest profit will be achieved when both farmers have 50 cows each. In this case each farmer will make a total profit of $5,425,000.
d.
The grazing land was traditionally more common unlike today due to the explosion of population and urbanisation. A large proportion of land has been used up for settlement which used to be grazing land. This is the reason why grazing is no more practiced widely.
Comments
Leave a comment